Comparison between Spark ignition and combustion ignition engines

 

Comparison between Spark ignition and combustion ignition engines

S.No.

Aspects

SI ENGINE

CI ENGINE

1.

THERMODYNAMIC CYCLE

It used the Otto cycle

(constant volume cycle)

[heat addition at constant volume and reject constant volume]

Diesel cycle(constant pressure cycle)[heat addition at constant pressure and reject at constant volume]

Dual cycle(heat addition at constant pressure and volume and heat reject occur at constant volume)

2.

Fuel

Petrol

Diesel

3.

Ignition type/combustion type use

Spark plug is used for combustion(Spark ignition)

Combustion is occur due to high compression no spark plug is used

4.

Speed

High speed 2200 to 6500 rpm
these kind are use in car and light vehicle

Low speed 500 to 3500 rpm

They are used for heavy vehicles because of high torque capacity

5.

Cost

Low cost from the fact petrol engine are lighter than diesel engine. so less amount in making and running (lower the weight higher the energy utilization)

High cost Diesel engine are very bulky and heavy. for heavy vehicles there size is huge

6.

Power capacity

They are lower power producing engine that is the reason truck and other heavy vehicles does not made of engine that use petrol

They are high power producing. Nearly every heavy vehicle designed for diesel engine

7.

Air fuel ratio

10:1 to 20:1

18:1 to 100:1

8.

Repairing /maintenance cost

Low cost as define in point no.5

High cost due to heavy engine and parts

9.

Working under Two stroke

Not suitable due to scavenging effect which cause fuel loss

Better suitable

10.

Compression ratio

Normally it is 6to 9 and go maximum to 11
at maximum limit anti knock effect occur

Normally 13 to 19

Maximum 25

Maximum limit is thermal stress and mechanical stress

11.

Safety

Petrol is more volatile so it more dangerous than diesel

Diesel is less volatile so it is more safe

12.

Efficiency

Low efficiency

High efficiency

13

Calorific value of fuel

44MJ/kg

42MJ/kg

14

weight

Light in weight

Heavy in weight because of the heavy engine making

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments