Comparison between Spark ignition and combustion ignition engines
|
S.No. |
Aspects |
SI ENGINE |
CI ENGINE |
|
1. |
THERMODYNAMIC CYCLE |
It used the Otto cycle (constant volume cycle) [heat addition at constant volume and reject constant
volume] |
Diesel cycle(constant pressure cycle)[heat addition at
constant pressure and reject at constant volume] Dual cycle(heat
addition at constant pressure and volume and heat reject occur at
constant volume) |
|
2. |
Fuel |
Petrol |
Diesel |
|
3. |
Ignition type/combustion type use |
Spark plug is used for combustion(Spark ignition) |
Combustion is occur due to high compression no spark plug is used |
|
4. |
Speed |
High speed 2200 to 6500 rpm |
Low speed 500 to 3500 rpm They are used for heavy vehicles because of high torque capacity |
|
5. |
Cost |
Low cost from the fact petrol engine are lighter than diesel engine. so
less amount in making and running (lower the weight higher the energy
utilization) |
High cost Diesel engine are very bulky and heavy. for heavy vehicles
there size is huge |
|
6. |
Power capacity |
They are lower power producing engine that is the reason truck and
other heavy vehicles does not made of engine that use petrol |
They are high power producing. Nearly every heavy vehicle designed
for diesel engine |
|
7. |
Air fuel ratio |
10:1 to 20:1 |
18:1 to 100:1 |
|
8. |
Repairing /maintenance cost |
Low cost as define in point no.5 |
High cost due to heavy engine and parts |
|
9. |
Working under Two stroke |
Not suitable due to scavenging effect which cause fuel loss |
Better suitable |
|
10. |
Compression ratio |
Normally it is 6to 9 and go maximum to 11 |
Normally 13 to 19 Maximum 25 Maximum limit is thermal stress and mechanical stress |
|
11. |
Safety |
Petrol is more volatile so it more dangerous than diesel |
Diesel is less volatile so it is more safe |
|
12. |
Efficiency |
Low efficiency |
High efficiency |
|
13 |
Calorific value of fuel |
44MJ/kg |
42MJ/kg |
|
14 |
weight |
Light in weight |
Heavy in weight because of the heavy engine making |
0 Comments
if you are not getting it then ask i am glad to help